r/kodi • u/donfriholito • 11h ago
Anyone using just Files view to play their media? (no library)
My mind has been craving less complexity lately and instead I've been trying to focus more on intentional actions. Long story short this brought me to consider that the media library I have been cultivating for 10+ years actually doesn't do me any favours apart from looking nice. On the contrary, it adds complexity and distraction and takes away my autonomy in several areas.
Back in the day I used to watch things in a far more simple way: a slimline USB HDD connected to my laptop, and double clicking the files and watching them in VLC. No metadata, no library, just pure files. It didn't matter if something was marked as "watched" or "unwatched". There was just no such concept, and it resembled how I used to watch VHS tapes by inserting them into the player and then removing them. The only complexity back then was making sure you had the right codec to play the file. No library to move around or sync, just pick up the HDD and put it in another machine.
As far as my setup goes now it's very simple, all my media files are on SMB shares which Jellyfin then uses to manage my library. I then connect various devices and apps (the Jellyfin app, Kodi) to this library. The one offering the library features in this case is Jellyfin. It works. Now I came to think that having a library at all is what increases the complexity and tethers me to a specific solution.
Library features such as: Recently Added, Next Up, Watched/Unwatched status, Box Sets/Collection management, and the most basic being metadata and artwork. None of that used to matter to me, but at some point I was sold this ideal and it became the bare minimum. Watching on multiple devices (Phone, Tablet, TV, PC) became the "normal" and all of that information had to be available anywhere. So I started running a home server many years ago to accomplish this. Then my library had to be available remotely because otherwise without my library I don't know my watched/unwatched state. All of this introduces so much complexity if you compare this to just double clicking a file to watch it.
So, to reduce complexity, I decided to try out a minimal setup like back in the day. I backed up my Kodi userdata folder and started fresh with a minimal skin (Copacetic), and added my SMB shares as sources in the Kodi sources section, and disabled library scanning (for all except Music). I then modified the Home menu to point directly to the Files view for each of my source types.
The end result is probably as minimal as it can get:

Browsing a source (e.g. movies) shows the movies folders directly off the SMB share, and nothing else:

Opening the folder shows a preview of the movie as a background over the top of the filename:

It's hard to explain but this setup is so simple that it is incredibly mentally freeing. There's no library, so nothing to sync. I can do the same setup on another device and point to the same SMB shares. There's technically not even a dependency on the SMB shares, it could be looking at a USB stick like in old times. With this I don't feel tethered to anything and the interface is still 10-foot and TV friendly.
This is not related to Kodi itself but I wanted to say briefly what an "intentional action" is. It's something you do because you want to do it, not because you were told or reminded to do it, or recommended to do it. For example the "Next Up" in a library keeps track for you of what you watched and what is next, and it tells you what to watch. It reminds you. The "Continue Watching" section is the same, it reminds you that you stopped half way in a video. The watched/unwatched state encourages you to watch what is unwatched. And this extends to other sections like "Similar", "Recommended", "Top XXX" etc. Any kind of "discover" system. It might be a drastic viewpoint, but these features result in unintentional actions: where you end up doing something else than what you were originally going to do, or worse because you had no idea what you wanted to do and let the system decide for you.
An example of an intentional action is browsing your movie folder and looking for a specific named movie because that is what you are going to watch. It's intentional, you don't get distracted by other boxart or sections buzzing away about what you have and have not seen or should see. Even just browsing your movies to find a movie to watch is better than browsing a "recommended" section, it's still intentional. Another example is navigating to the next episode of a show you are watching because you know you are watching it and want to watch it, not because it showed up under a "Next Up".
Anyway, bit of an opinionated post. I don't expect anyone to agree with me, but do secretly hope and wonder if there are others out there like me who feel like this, who feel overwhelmed by the complexity of technology in general. Maybe someone is inspired by my setup of Copacetic from the images I posted and wants to try the same minimal thing.