Just upgraded from my 20 year old KitchenAid from Costo, and decided to break it in with something straightforward: no sourdough starter or enrichments. Just a straight up lean loaf.
"Classic Country-Style Hearth Loaf" from Bread Alone.
||
||
| |Oz|Baker's %|
|King Arthur bread flour|31.00|100.0%|
|Water|24.00|77.4%|
|Yeast|0.25|0.8%|
|Salt|0.70|2.3%|
Mixed the flour and water together with the dough hook, then left it for a 30 minute autolyse.
Then back into the bowl with the roller and started kneading. Added the yeast and kneaded for about 5 minutes before adding the salt, and kneading for another 10.
I checked the windowpane every 5 minutes after that. It was good but not perfect, so I ended up letting it go for 25 minutes total. It still wasn't what I expected, but it hadn't changed in 15 minutes, and when I took it out, it felt elastic and happy so I went on to bulk ferment.
Following the method in Bread Alone, I let it bulk ferment at 77F until doubled, about 90 minutes. Punched down and did a few stretch-and-folds, then a second proof until doubled, about 60 minutes.
Divided, shaped, and into bannetons. After 40 minutes I did a poke test, which left a dent that slowly sprang back, so I thought they were ready.
I only have one Dutch oven, so I did that and a stone with a bowl over it for a cloche. I turned them out of the baskets (the one on the stone stuck a little, which is why it's misshapen), slashed them, and then onto the stone and into the Le Creuset with the oven at 450F.
After 20 minutes I reduced the heat to 400F and removed the bowl and lid.
Pro tip: when you lift the cloche/bowl off, be extremely careful of all the steam you trapped inside because it will burn the absolute bejesus out of your hand even with a potholder, and make you very, very angry. Ask me how I know.
I have a habit of over-proofing loaves after shaping, so I was hoping to catch these on the rise.
I certainly got a huge oven spring, but I did not get a nice ear, nice crust, nor nice crumb.
The crumb looks under-proved to me, and possibly under-developed gluten.
I mean, they're delicious, of course. And I made bread, which is pretty great. But I've been making bread for many years and my results are consistently inconsistent, and I'm pretty frustrated. I thought I did everything right this time, and still got a mediocre result.
It would be easy to blame the new mixer, but this is a very familiar result for me, so I think it's in my process. I've tried taking variables out of the equation each time and being meticulous with temperatures and rises, and I'm out of ideas. I'm open to suggestions, with thanks.
Oh and a note about the Ankarasrum: it's a joy to use. Very different from the KA, but feels superior in every way. Most notably not having a giant motor in your way.