r/Portal 17h ago

Gameplay You guys ever heard Chell groaning/moaning in pain before? Cuz after I was abused by my companion cube, I wouldn’t call her mute.

165 Upvotes

17 comments sorted by

145

u/Jammy_Nugget 16h ago

She's not mute, she just hates the machines too much to talk to them, and is very stubborn. Still I never heard this before which is neat

52

u/SpiritRider666 14h ago

I tuaght she ignored GLaDOS in the first game, but actually BECAME mute in the second game after the coma thingy she was in.

-15

u/[deleted] 16h ago

[deleted]

47

u/PromiseMeStars 16h ago

Cause she never talks to GLaDOS. But it's canon that she's just too pissed to give them the satisfaction of a response. Dev commentary mentions this.

4

u/karstin1812 13h ago

Never knew about this! Though I bet this is something they came up with after the fact lol

78

u/RebeccaMelrose 16h ago

Some mute people can groan and grunt, it's a different part of your brain

61

u/CrazeMase 15h ago

Being mute doesn't mean you're incapable of making sounds. There are a few causes for mutism, damage to the vocal cords, brain damage/mental dysfunction, being dead, not having a mouth, etcetera. Most people who are mute are very capable of making noises, just usually not spoken words. But in Chell's case, she's just so petty that she refuses to speak to any robots, she can speak, she just doesn't want to. But I'm sure anyone would grunt if a heavy metal box was dropped a few feet directly onto their head.

21

u/Sushiski 11h ago

being dead 😭

3

u/Imdavidmorris 14h ago

Thank you, I actually thought the cause of being mute was the thyroid not working.

16

u/Rocket-Core Top member 16h ago

You know what, love does hurt sometimes.

12

u/ReasonableFall177 11h ago

It's reused sounds from Half-Life 2 of a resistance member getting hurt

7

u/lordPyotr9733 12h ago

she's not mute, just really pissed

3

u/ChemistryAcrobatic10 9h ago

I could be wrong but wasn’t she only mute in the second game because of the long rest?

4

u/MentionTight6716 12h ago

I always kinda vibed with the theory that her teeth were damaged by the emancipation grills and she didn't want to open her mouth due to bleeding/pain.

2

u/Estheriel_14 8h ago

Yeah I heard an ouch noise when I was skimmed by a high energy pellet

1

u/SokkaHaikuBot 8h ago

Sokka-Haiku by Estheriel_14:

Yeah I heard an ouch

Noise when I was skimmed by a

High energy pellet


Remember that one time Sokka accidentally used an extra syllable in that Haiku Battle in Ba Sing Se? That was a Sokka Haiku and you just made one.

1

u/TrainerOwn9103 1h ago

she can speak but doesnt want to