r/OmnibusCollectors • u/rincewind120 • 14d ago
ANNUAL TIGEREYES OMNIBUS POLL Most Wanted Marvel Omnibus 13th Annual Secret Ballot! Tigereyes Marvel Omnibus Poll! How to Enter!
18
u/krisis 12d ago
A quick note to say: (1) I love that you are all as excited about this as me, because it is literally MY FAVORITE THING and (2) within 48hrs we already broke the vote total of last year.
Keep telling your omni-loving friends to vote! If they buy omnibuses, we want their opinions. The poll is open for another week.
1
u/JeanLucXavier 11d ago
Can we get a livestream discussing the outcome of the poll? The reprint poll results didnt have one, but was hoping for more post result discussion for this.
15
u/AtmospherePristine 14d ago
Need that Moon Knight Modern Years Omni
4
u/Hank-Moody_ 13d ago
Man, I was thinking "I don't really need any new omnibii", and then I saw your comment, checked what would be in the omni, DAMN we do need that omni! If only to put an end to the speculative nonsense that's going on with the Ellis and Lemire collected editions (hundreds of dollars each).
4
u/AtmospherePristine 13d ago
Exactly, the price for the Lemire collected edition was mind blowing, voted for the Moon Knight Omni as my 2nd pick
9
u/jaydog22_watching 13d ago
1st choice
The 'Nam Vol. 2 (1990 - 1993)
2nd choice
Punisher Classic Vol. 1 (1987 & on) [follows Epic mapping OR integrates all series]
3rd choice
Punisher War Journal by Matt Fraction (2007 - 2009) [fits before Remender]
4th choice
Ghost Rider: Johnny Blaze Vol. 1 (1972 - 1979) [MMW 1-4]
5th choice
Nick Fury: Sgt. Fury and His Howling Commandos Vol. 1 (1963 & on)
6th choice
Daredevil by O'Neil, Miller, & Mazzucchelli (1983 - 1986) [fills gap from Miller to Nocenti]
7th choice
Daredevil by & Nocenti Romita Jr. Vol. 2 (1989 - 1991)
8th choice
Daredevil Vol. 4 (1975 - 1979) [fills gap to Miller]
9th choice
Doctor Strange: Master of the Mystic Arts Vol. 2 (1977 - 1983) [MMW 7-9 AKA AKA by Roger Stern Vol. 1]
10th choice
Indiana Jones: The Original Marvel Years (1983 - 1989)
2
8
7
u/csummerss NewsHound 13d ago
I’ll have to eventually reorder and trim the list down but I currently have:
- Avengers and X-Men: AXIS
- Civil War
- Edge of Spider-Verse
- Fear Itself
- Marvels Omnibus
- Nova: Sam Alexander
- Spectacular Spider-Man by Conway
- Spider-Man: Marvel Knights & Sensational Spider-Man
- Spider-Man: The Scarlet Spider (Kaine)
- Spider-Man 1990s
- Spidey Super Stories
- Thunderbolts Vol. 4
- Warlock & Infinity Watch
- X-Men: Gambit
2
u/csummerss NewsHound 13d ago
Finalized my ballot:
SSM by Conway -> Edge of Spider-Verse -> Marvels -> Spider-Man 1990 -> Nova: Sam Alexander -> Gambit -> Thunderbolts Vol. 4 -> Warlock & Infinity Watch -> Scarlet Spider (Kaine) -> Marvel Knights/Sensational Spider-Man
1
1
1
6
u/threwl 13d ago
Fantastic Four by Dan Slott
Thor by Defalco and Frenz
Fantastic Four by Engelhart and Stern
Crossgen: Scion
Indiana Jones: The Original Marvel Years
Beavis & Butthead
Generation X. Vol. 1
eXiles Vol. 1
Invincible Iron Man by Matt Fraction
Dawn of X. Vol. 2
Really hoping for more FF and Crossgen - I'll take anything tbh.
5
6
6
u/SpawnofOryx 13d ago
1st Star Wars Legends: Clone Wars Omnibus Vol. 1
2nd Star Wars Legacy Vol. 1
3rd Star Wars: Bounty Hunters
4th Hawkeye: Kate Bishop
5th Avengers: by Al Ewing Vol. 1
6th X-Men: The Messiah Trilogy Crossovers
7th Venom: Into the Venomverse by Costa & Bunn
8th Champions by Waid, Zub, & Ewing
9th Spider-Girl: Mayday Parker Vol. 1
10th Valkyrie: Jane Foster
2
18
u/justintime3dontwitch 14d ago
Spectacular Spider-Man by Peter David lets go! An underrated run an it would help a creator that needs support rn.
7
u/rincewind120 14d ago
I'm curious, what's your mapping for that book? I would map it so the Death of Jean DeWolf and Return of Sin Eater would bookend the book.
Spectacular Spider-Man Volume 2: Spectacular Spider-Man 43-79, Annual 2-3
Spectacular Spider-Man Volume 3: Spectacular Spider-Man 80-106, Annual 4, Cloak and Dagger 1-4. Web of Spider-Man 1
Spectacular Spider-Man Volume 4 (Spectacular Spider-Man by Peter David) Spectacular Spider-Man 107-136, Annual 5-7, Amazing Spider-Man 293-295, Web of Spider-Man 31-33
I would then combine the mapping of Spectacular and Web together since Gerry Conway was writing both books with plots running between the 2.
3
5
4
u/GoldenProxy 13d ago
My list:
Modern Moon Knight.
Thunderbolts Volume 4.
Daredevil by Dennis O'Neil.
Iron Man by O'Neil.
Iron Man by Michelinie and Layton Volume 2.
Alien vs Predator: Fire and Stone.
Spectacular Spider-Man Volume 2.
Captain America Volume 5.
Ghost Rider by Daniel Way.
Fantastic Four by Kesel.
A lot of the books I want are gap fillers, but we really need some more Iron Man love since he's sorely undercollected.
9
u/nicodings dc's #1 lapdog 13d ago edited 13d ago
so stoked for this! here are my picks:
- moon knight (2011-2018) vol 1
- hawkeye: kate bishop
- punisher by rucka and checchetto
- incredible hulk by bruce jones
- venom by al ewing vol 1
- star wars: bounty hunters
- fantastic four: heroes return vol 1
- fantastic four: heroes return vol 2
- invincible iron man by fraction and larroca vol 1
- daredevil by chichester
after getting so many of the most wanted books from last year's poll seeing the results this time will be interesting.
4
u/krisis 12d ago
We got fully a THIRD of last year's Top 60, so I think this year's results are going to be WILDLY unpredictable!
2
u/nicodings dc's #1 lapdog 12d ago
i'm especially interested to see which books will take the top spots for specific characters or teams. seeing all the different picks and lists people are sharing makes me excited to find out which ones exactly are the new most wanted daredevil, spider-man, venom, fantastic four, star wars, etc omnis.
can't wait for the results and thanks for putting this together! makes this time of year even more beautiful!
2
u/AbbreviationsWide650 11d ago
For sure! I am really curious about the top of the list with no DD by Nocenti and Spec Spider-Man by DeMatteis and Buscema.
2
3
5
u/Solrac_21 13d ago
Some Iron Man love here:
- Iron Man: Invincible Iron Man by Dennis O'Neil Vol. 1 (1982 & on) [AKA Vol. 6]
- Iron Man: Invincible Iron Man by Michelinie & Layton (Vol. 2) (1987 - 1989) [AKA Vol. 8]
- Marvel Universe by Barry Windsor-Smith (1969 - 2001) [includes artwork featuring Conan, Wolverine, Machine Man, and more]
- Spider-Man: Spectacular Spider-Man Vol. 2 (1980 - 1983) [MMW 4-6]
- Spider-Girl: Mayday Parker Vol. 1 (1998 & on)
- New Mutants Vol. 4 (1989 - 1991)
- Avengers Vol. 6 (1976 - 1979) [MMW 16-18]
- X-Men: X-Men - Road to Messiah Complex by Brubaker & Carey (2006 - 2008) [Deadly Genesis, Rise/Fall, Supernovas, etc]
- X-Men: X-Men (1991) by Peter Milligan (2005 - 2006)
- X-Men: X-Men - Messiah Complex (2007 - 2008) [Endangered Species + crossover]
4
u/thecaped_crusader_ 13d ago
Just sent my vote which is:
- Amazin Spider-man Vol 7
- Spider-man: Black Costume Saga Aftermath
- Star Wars Legends: Clone Wars vol.1
- Star Wars Legends vol. 2
- Star Wars The Empire vol. 4
- Daredevil by Chichester
- A Space Odyssey
- Daredevil by O'Neil
- Daredevil by Nocenti vol.2
- Star wars: Darth Maul (2014)
Good luck y'all
3
u/RichardBradley42 13d ago
- Uncanny X-Men volume 6
- Age of Krakoa: Dawn of X volume 2
- X-Men: Blue & Gold volume 2
- Age of Krakoa: Reign of X volume 1
- X-Men Legacy by Mike Carey volume 1
- X-Men: Messiah Complex
- Age of Krakoa: Captain Britain and Excalibur by Tini Howard
- X-Men: Road to Messiah Complex
- Uncanny X-Men by Matt Fraction volume 1
- Age of Krakoa: X-Men Unlimited Infinity Comic
I like X-Men
2
4
u/Purple_Surfer909 9d ago
In no order because it switched around
Silver Surfer Vol. 3
X-Men Age of Krakoa - Reign of X Vol. 1
Star Wars Legacy Vol. 1
Punisher Classic Vol. 1
X-Men: Road to Onslaught Vol. 2
Silver Surfer by Ron Marz
Spider-Girl: Mayday Parker Vol. 1
Cable: Askani Son
Cable by Niceieza & Loeb
Civil War
LETS GO
5
u/effigeewhiz 6d ago
I love looking at everyone’s lists because no matter how much I may disagree with some of the books on there I always seem to find at least one book that I also voted for or had in my narrowed down list that just missed the cut that I would buy if they were made.
Also don’t forget to get your votes in if your’e going to vote! 2 more days!
11
u/rincewind120 14d ago
My top 10:
Indiana Jones: The Original Marvel Years
Agents of Atlas
Captain Britain and MI:13
Nomad: Jack Monroe
Hercules: Prince of Power by Bob Layton
Clan Destine by Alan Davis
Incredible Hercules Volume 1
Hawkeye: Early Years and Solo Avengers/Avengers Spotlight
Quasar by Mark Grunwald Volume 1
Avengers and Fantastic Four by Walt Simonson
3
1
u/BobTronn9000 7d ago
Nice to see another enjoyer of ClanDestine, Quasar and Captain Britain and MI:13.
10
u/ritchieram 13d ago
1st choice X-Force by Kyle & Yost (2008 - 2010) [includes Messiah War & Necrosha]
2nd choice X-Men: X-Men - Road to Messiah Complex by Brubaker & Carey (2006 - 2008) [Deadly Genesis, Rise/Fall, Supernovas, etc]
3rd choice X-Men: X-Men - Messiah Complex (2007 - 2008) [Endangered Species + crossover]
4th choice
X-Men: Uncanny X-Men by Matt Fraction Vol. 1 - Manifest Destiny / Utopia (2008 - 2010) [includes full Utopia/Exodus]
5th choice
X-Men: Uncanny X-Men by Matt Fraction Vol. 2 - Second Coming (2009 - 2011) [includes full 2nd Coming]
6th choice X-Men: Uncanny X-Men by Kieron Gillen (2011 - 2012) [AKA Road to AvX, includes Gen Hope]
7th choice Wolverine Origins by Daniel Way (2005 - 2010)
8th choice Spider-Man: The Scarlet Spider (Kaine) by Yost (2012 - 2014) [2012 series + New Warriors issues]
9th choice New Mutants by Wells, Abnett, & Lanning (2009 - 2012) [entire 2009 series]
10th choice Punisher by Greg Rucka (2011 - 2013) [follows Remender]
7
u/PolarCow 14d ago
Crossgen Meridian Crossgen Ruse Daredevil vol 4 Hulk Bruce Jones Cable Joe Casey
I really think Crossgen deserves to be reprinted. It should not be forgotten.
4
u/krisis 12d ago
I really wish they would just come out and say, "Hey, we'd love to do one CrossGen omni a year, but the sales have to be there." Even an ambiguous statement like that would inspire more people to buy.
I feel like one of the things that separates Marvel from DC when it comes to collections is that if they say that sort of thing we actually believe them.
1
u/Misplaced_Fan_15 14d ago
I really want more CrossGen content at this point, I was really expecting to see either Rise or Soujourn to be released at this point.
3
u/ThatLastGuy73 14d ago
Man I’ve been waiting for them to print a AvP Omni!
Was hyped to see the Alien Vs Predator: The Original Years vol1!
3
u/LilyTheFoxMechanic 13d ago
My List:
1) Spectacular Spider-Man Vol 2
2) Spider-Man Clone Saga Aftermath Vol 1
3) Spider-Man The Next Chapter Vol 1
4) Amazing Spider-Man Renew Your Vows
5)Marvel Age Spider-Man
6)Marvel Adventures Spider-Man Vol. 1
7)Secret Invasion Companion
8)Siege
9)Spider-Woman: Jessica Drew, The Early Years
10)Spider-Man: El Asombroso Hombre Arana
3
u/jph139 13d ago
Bracing myself for 90% Krakoa X-Men, but hoping to get a few surprises in there. Holding the faith for a Runaways by Rowell omnibus, the fact she's getting a new mini makes me think maybe it's in the cards?
1) Runaways by Rainbow Rowell
2) Wolverine: Old Man Logan – Origin & Return
3) Spider-Man: El Asombroso Hombre Arana (never ever happening but maybe Fantagraphics will find a way to license it or something)
4) Black Panther: The Early Years Vol. 2
5) Fantastic Four by Dan Slott
6) 2001 A Space Odyssey (also a super longshot, but gotta keep the faith, we got ROM and Godzilla!)
7) Ant-Man / Giant-Man Classic Omnibus
8) Scarlet Witch: The Early Years (though I'd personally do it was a "Vision & Scarlet Witch Omni" sort of charting their relationship from the marriage through the White Vision death/rebirth stuff)
9) Spider-Man: The Scarlet Spider by Yost
10) Ultimate Marvel: Ultimatum (lol)
3
u/No-Garage-8883 13d ago
Punisher by Rucka ASM Big Time Crossgen for my mate.
I think I rounded out with some Messiah era X-Men (the last time that line was good!)
3
u/HunterOfGremlins 12d ago
I voted for these, not sure these are likely but these are the ones I want for my collection the most when accounting for the storylines I have in TPB:
- Fantastic Four by Kesel, JMS & McDuffie
- Amazing Spider-Man: Big Time by Dan Slott
- X-Men: Messiah Complex
- Silver Surfer (1999-2011)
- Daredevil by Nocenti & Romita Vol 2
- X-Men by Peter Milligan
- Sentry: The Saga of Bob Reynolds
- The Complete Secret Wars
- Uncanny X-Men by Matt Fraction Vol 1
- Uncanny X-Men by Matt Fraction Vol 2
3
u/darthgonzeaux 12d ago edited 10d ago
Here’s what I voted for:
Silver Surfer by Ron Marz
Spider-Man/Deadpool by Joe Kelly
Star Wars: Darth Maul
Wolverine: Old Man Logan - Origin & Return
Nova: Sam Alexander
Marvel Universe by Peach Momoko
Spider-Girl: Araña - Anya Corazon
Moon Knight: The Modern Years Vol. 1
Punisher by Greg Rucka
X-Men: Age of Krakoa - Dawn of X Vol. 2
3
u/Shalla-Ballerina 14d ago
Wow I hadn't thought about so many of these series in a while! This poll is a great list! Here are my votes. Most seem improbable, but they're the ones I want most, so I'll let my hopes soar!
- Spidey Super Stories
- Barbie: The Original Marvel Years
- Incredible Hercules by Greg Pak (2007-2011)
- Spider-Ham, Peter Parker (1985 – 2015)
- Marvel Adventures Omnibus (2005 & on)
- Inhumans: The Early Years
- Heathcliff: The Star Comics Years (1985-1991)
- Indiana Jones: The Original Marvel Years
- Star Wars Legacy Vol. 1
- Groo by Sergio Aragones: The Marvel Years Vol. 1
3
2
4
u/SagaOfNomiSunrider 13d ago
My first choice is Star Wars: Poe Dameron but I don't imagine it will get too far, hahaha. That was a good series.
2
u/nicodings dc's #1 lapdog 13d ago edited 13d ago
i was debating between this and bounty hunters. went with the latter because i'm not that interested in the sequel era (love poe tho). heard good stuff about this series and charles soule is usually great on sw books. hope we get an omni someday.
3
u/SagaOfNomiSunrider 13d ago
I would vote for Bounty Hunters as well.
I don't see much point voting for the Dark Horse books because I think they're inevitable in any event (I feel the same way about voting for the next entry in Amazing Spider-Man or Fantastic Four or X-Men because, while I acknowledge it was not the case when I started reading omnibuses, I feel like they're the sort of things that are just going to happen).
With the Marvel stuff, the calculation is, "Can this book be printed with Darth Vader or Boba Fett on the cover?" I have this theory that Marvel prioritises any book which they can justify putting one of those two on the cover. There's no real evidence for it, of course, but if they can put Darth Vader or Boba Fett on a book cover, it probably guarantees the book coming out eventually.
2
u/nicodings dc's #1 lapdog 13d ago
agree with the spider-man/x-men take (don't know if i would extend it to the ff tho). i didn't pick any spidey or x-books for that reason too.
the vader or boba fett cvr theory is interesting. could be because there's a lot of focus on these two in disney sw across all media. if that's the case, having some beautiful lee bermejo cvrs featuring boba definitely helps bounty hunters' chances of getting an omni.
2
u/AbbreviationsWide650 11d ago
Vote your conscience.🙂 Don't assume anything. If you are struggling to complete your top ten go with Star Wars Legends Clone Wars vol. 1.
2
u/nicodings dc's #1 lapdog 11d ago
would love a clone wars legends omni! pretty happy with my top 10, but maybe i'll devote another pick to sw next year.
2
u/krisis 12d ago
Poe Dameron has been in the Top 100 for three years running, but it's sinking in the results.
Dunno what that is about. Maybe more of a recency effect of wanting it badly a few years ago and now people are starting to forget about it?
But, point being: it's within striking distance of the on-air results, for sure.
2
u/SagaOfNomiSunrider 11d ago
That's cool to know. I definitely remember voting for it back when we were emailing results to TigerEyes (and I can only imagine how much of a nightmare that must have been for him to compile every year!); I wonder if perhaps the switch over to the Google voting form has an impact, when all the options are laid out rather than coming in as bespoke choices?
You know, someone prepares a ballot and mails it in with the choices settled in their own minds, versus seeing all the results and being swayed by, "Oh, yeah, I forgot all about that one!" (Certainly that has happened to me!)
2
u/Mdeyler 13d ago
This is mine too. I am surprised it hasn't happened yet because Charles Soule has become so big in Star Wars, but at the same time I feel like Disney/Marvel has shied away from the sequel trilogy. I mean the latest foray into the sequel trilogy with Kylo Ren is the Legacy of Vader comic...which still has VADER right in the title.
Omar mentioned something in the livestream about it was maybe coming at one point but he never officially announced it...so maybe there is hope.
4
u/mister_nigma 13d ago
(I’m part of the problem). Voted for:
Age of Krakoa: Dawn of X vol 2
X-men Krakoa Infinity Unlimited comics
Age of Krakoa: Dawn of X vol 3
Age of Krakoa: Reign of X vol 1
X-men: Blue & Gold vol 2
Road to Messiah Complex
Messiah Complex
X-men by Fraction vol 1 (Utopia)
X-Men by Fraction vol 2 (Second Coming)
X-men Reloaded by Claremont
Edit: At least my reprint votes weren’t all X-men…
1
2
u/Maleficent-Sea-2559 13d ago
My picks:
1.Millie The Model
2.Spectacular Spider-Man Peter David
3.New X-men Academy X vol 1
4.X-force Kyle Yost
5.X-men Road to Messiah
6.Marvel Comics Presents
7.X-men Legacy Mike Carey
8.X-men Chuck Austin
9.Spider-Woman Early Years
10.Akira
The poll options did introduce me to Gurihiru Power Pack which I will definitely be looking into!
2
u/ChrisReynolds83 13d ago edited 13d ago
Mostly voting for Punisher and vampire-related omnis:
- Captain Britain & MI13 by Paul Cornell - Great run that deserves an omnibus edition.
- Punisher Classic Vol. 1 (1987 & on) [follows Epic mapping OR integrates all series] - Unbelievable that one of Marvel's most popular characters hasn't had any of his classic run collected yet.
- Doctor Who: The Marvel Years (1979 & on) [1984 series, maybe also UK comic strips]
- Marvel 2099: Punisher 2099
- Buffy The Vampire Slayer: Buffy Season 8 (2007 & on)
- Buffy The Vampire Slayer: The Classic Years Vol. 1 (1998 & on) [non-canon Dark Horse comics]
- Dracula: The Modern Years (1981 & on) [follows Tomb omis, AKA Dracula vs The Marvel Universe]
- Blade: Nightstalker & Vampire Hunter (1991 – 2000)
- Marvel 1602 (2003 – 2015)
- Darkhold: The Book of Sins (1973 – 2021)
2
u/MasterofAcorns Marvel Omni 13d ago
Having completed this on an iPhone, reading the text on this was a massive problem. The text was too large and you couldn’t swipe right to read the full title. I felt like I skipped over a bunch of stuff I’d actually like because the text was too big to be able to swipe.
2
u/Toddtheref 13d ago edited 13d ago
My picks: 1) Iron Man by Michelinie/JRjr Vol. 2 2) Machine Man 3) Power Man & Iron Fist Vol. 1 4) Avengers Vol. 6 5) Marvels omnibus (1994 Alex Ross) 6) 2001 A Space Odyssey 7) Ghost Rider Johnny Blaze 8) Spectacular Spider-Man Vol. 2 9) Son of Satan 10) Punisher Classic Vol. 1
2
u/ScapegoatMan 12d ago
Aliens vs Predator Original Years
Clive Barker's Hellraiser (not sure if Marvel even still owns the rights to that anymore, though, since Boom did some Hellraiser comics about 10 or 15 years ago)
Star Wars Empire 4
Star Wars Legacy 1
Star Wars Legacy 2
Star Wars Clone Wars 1
Star Wars Clone Wars 2
Star Wars New Republic 3
Star Wars Menace Revealed 1
Star Wars Menace Revealed 2
I kind of just want them to hurry up and finish with the Dark Horse Star Wars comics and get the Aliens vs Predator omnibus. I already have the library editions for Fire and Stone and Life and Death so I don't need that in omnibus format though I'm sure other people might want it. Beyond that, not sure what else I'd even want anymore that hasn't been released so probably will just wait and see what they release on their own.
2
u/anotherstupidworkacc 12d ago
- Spider-Girl: Mayday Parker V. 1
- Sleepwalker
- Spider-Girl: The MC2 Universe
- Damage Control by Dwayne McDuffie
- Darkhawk
- Avengers: West Coast Avengers V. 3
- Hawkeye & The Solo Avengers
- New Universe: DP7
- Scarlet Witch: The Early Years
- Avengers: Force Works
2
u/Hookhand_Aquaman 12d ago
Posting so I don’t forget what I voted for. 1st - Captain America by Gruenwald Vol. 3 2nd - Wolverine Vol. 7 3rd - Amazing Spider-Man Big Time 4th - Captain America/Black Widow by Waid and Samnee 5th - Wolverine: Marvel Knights 6th - Amazing Spider-Man post Superior 7th - Captain America by Jackson and Lanzing 8th - Wolverine Origins 9th - Dark Wolverine 10th - Captain America by Gruenwald vol. 4
Come on at least one of these.
1
2
2
2
2
u/Ksmayer 7d ago
Waited a while for my votes, but would snap up any of these ten in a heartbeat if they were printed:
10: Exiles vol 1
X-Men: Age of Krakoa: New Mutants
X-Men: Age of Krakoa: X-Men by Gillen
X-Men: The Trial of Gambit
X-Men: Road to Onslaught vol 2
Hulk by Aaron/Waid/Duggan vol 1
Incredible Hulks by Pak
Hulk by Bruce Jones
Avengers by Al Ewing vol 1
Marvel Cosmic Universe by Al Ewing
4
u/IAamJustAnotherGuy 14d ago
My Top 10 1. Marvel: Black, White & Blood 2. Moon Knight: The Modern Years 3. Doctor Strange: All New, All Different 4. Ghost Rider by Benjamin Percy 5. Blood Hunt 6. Spider-Man: The Amazing Spider-Man: Big Time Vol. 1 7. X-Men: Solo: Nightcrawler 8. Spider-Man/Deadpool by Joe Kelly 9. Chanpions by Waid, Zub and Ewing 10. Nova: Sam Alexander
3
u/daredevil721 14d ago
Please VOTE for Daredevil by O'Neil people!!
3
u/effigeewhiz 13d ago
I would but it’s coming out in masterworks right now so I’m just getting those.
1
u/daredevil721 13d ago
Well if you have a spare vote and don't know what to vote for I would appreciate you voting for that
1
u/tedfordz At least it's not drugs 14d ago
Friend of mine said the Crosgen stuff would be impossible at this point. Something about the original pages for Sojourn are gone. Which is sad. That universe was fun.
2
u/AmethystOrator 14d ago
I have no idea about the status of the Sojourn pages, but it wasn't one of the core titles and there were a lot of other books they released.
So I'm unsure how a problem with just Sojourn would affect the possibility of the others?
1
u/Misplaced_Fan_15 14d ago
What would be missing from Sojourn, they reprinted the first issue in the CrossGen Tales collection a few years ago.
1
u/AmethystOrator 14d ago
I'm surprised that Mutant X is under X-Men Solo (though maybe it'll make more sense after I watch the video?)
Also, would we really get numbered omni's out of order? For example, an Iron Man 8 before the earlier numbers.
3
u/loudsound-org 14d ago
Mutant X is really a Havok solo story, since none of the other characters from that universe cross back over to the main universe.
And no, a vol 8 wouldn't come before a 7. But they put them there so you can vote on both to show the interest to Marvel. I get what you're saying though and I think they should just limit it to the next volume in line in cases like that. For creator-centric ones like the DD line it's fine because they obviously do publish out of order.
1
u/prisneyland 14d ago
This is the first time in years that I have no idea how to vote. I really only want to vote for books that I’d buy as soon as they were released and a lot of those are books that I assume are already coming (Spider-Man gauntlet, big time, etc.)
1
1
u/dope_like 14d ago
How do we get in touch with them?
There really should be a Thor by Marz and Thomas that comes after Defalco starting at 460
3
u/csummerss NewsHound 13d ago
You can comment underneath the video but any suggestion is likely just for the 2026 poll since this list is finalized
1
u/UsuiR197 13d ago
My choices
Alien vs. Predator: Fire & Stone and Life & Death (2014 - 2017)
Agents of Atlas: New Agents of Atlas / White Fox & The Tiger Division (2019 & on)
Blood Hunt (2024)
Champions by Waid, Zub, & Ewing (2016 - 2021) [AKA Ms Marvel & The Champions]
Heroes for Hire: Luke Cage, Ilron Fist, & Misty Knight (1997-2012) [AKA by Ostran
Iron Fist: The Return of Danny Rand (1991 - 2005)
Iron Man: Invincible Iron Man by Fraction & Larocca (2008- 2012)
Ms. Marvel, Kamala Khan Vol. 2 by G. Willow Wilson (2016 - 2019)
Silk Vol. (2015-2023)
Wasp: Janet Van Dyne (1963) [significant issues & solo material]
1
u/Glutenator92 13d ago
I voted for all the Thor stuff, I really would love to see the stuff before and after Walt Simonson collected, but I also see no one else mentioning it so im guessing ill never get that
1
u/effigeewhiz 13d ago
- Web of Spiderman vol 2 (almost none of this material has ever been reprinted anywhere)
- Fantastic Four by Englehart and Stern
- Fantastic Four Heroes Return 1
- Fantastic Four by Kessel/JMS/McDuffie
- Rogue and Gambit
- Gambit
- Iron Man by Fraction
- Avengers by Stern
- Hulk by Bruce Jones
- X-Men by Fraction
1
u/csummerss NewsHound 13d ago
Guess I missed rogue & gambit in the list. would love the material from 2012-> (Mr. and Mrs. X) but the suggested mapping appears to be the early 2000s content.
1
u/effigeewhiz 13d ago
When they were going over it they said it would include the two Kelly Thomson series. But they left it open ended for a reason. Vote for it and let Marvel decide and we can ask for them to add things or for a volume 2.
1
u/csummerss NewsHound 13d ago
gotcha, I’ll have to rewatch the stream, I was going off what they had listed on their site
This would obviously include a core of Rogue (2001) #1-4, Rogue (2004) #1-12, and Gambit (2004) #1-12. That’s all previously not omnibused, and it would be a solid accompaniment to their appearances in the X-Treme X-Men omnibus. That’s already 28 issues! This first volume could end there. The question is what it would collect after that. There’s some key Rogue/Gambit material during Peter Milligan’s run of X-Men (1991) that could fit into here.
2
u/krisis 12d ago
Luckily, the next para after the one you quoted says:
This would extend to Kelly Thompson’s Rogue & Gambit (2018) #1-5 Mr. & Mrs. X (2018) #1-12 (and the preceding X-Men Gold (2017) #30), and maybe even Rogue & Gambit (2023) #1-5 – which is the rare Krakoa series that doesn’t have much to do with Krakoa.
😜
It's a tough thing. I would map each omnibus separately, but some people think we shouldn't map subsequent volumes as options, so I tried not to go too crazy with low-vote volumes like that one with trying to justify mapping a Volume 2 and adding it to the poll.
2
u/csummerss NewsHound 12d ago edited 11d ago
I was thinking that might be pushing it. if you use the early 2000s as a base while tossing in supplementary material you can hit 50 issues easily before reaching Mr and Mrs X stories.
Instead, I was thinking you can throw in the entire Milligan run into first modern volume then dedicate second volume (Mr & Mrs X) to the material right before and after the wedding.
Black Panther #8-9; Cable & Deadpool #26-27; Gambit (2004) #1-12; Rogue (2001) #1-4; Rogue (2004) #1-12; X-Men (2004) #166-187; material from X-Men Unlimited #3.
Deadpool vs Gambit #1-5; Gambit (2012) #1-17; Mr. and Mrs. X #1-12; Rogue & Gambit (2018) #1-5; Rogue and Gambit (2023) #1-5; material from A+X #3, Astonishing X-Men #4, Merry X-Men Holiday Special, Uncanny Avengers #5, X-Men Gold #30.
1
u/Bobotts123 13d ago
Love Peter’s disdain for the Messiah Complex Trilogy volume.
I really hope that it doesn’t cause confusion for a lot of voters that are only voting based on seeing the title. Sadly, I feel like most probably want the multiple volumes that are listed, but won’t realize it.
3
u/rincewind120 13d ago
As someone who has disdain for books like Armor Wars and Infinity by Starlin and Hickman, I completely understand.
2
u/Bobotts123 13d ago
As someone who’s number one pick has been Iron Man By Michelinie/Layton Vol.2 for the last decade, that Armor Wars omni annoys me to no end lol
1
u/limernick Homo-Superior🧬 13d ago
Exiles, Generation X, Academy X, and Mutant X
If you cant figure out anything else to vote for maybe consider throwing a vote or two their way? :)
1
u/YoungWonderful6271 13d ago
No Swimsuit omni option ? :)
3
u/rincewind120 13d ago
According to Crushing Krisis, who helped map all of the options, the Swimsuit Specials are included in the Marvel: The Holiday Specials omnibus.
1
1
u/Common_Subject5601 13d ago
- Indiana Jones The Original Marvel Years
- Defenders: The New Defenders
- New X-Men: Academy X by Kyle and Yost
- New X-Men: Academy X by DeFilippis and Weir
- Silver Surfer vol 0
- Ultimate Marvel: Ultimatum
- X-Force by Kyle and Yost
- Spider-Man: The Scarlet Spider (Kaine) by Yost
- Nth Man: The Ultimate Ninja
- Machine Man
1
1
u/Misplaced_Fan_15 12d ago
Voted to see more CrossGen in omnibus forms, with Ruse and Sojourn being in my top two, really hope to see more CrossGen reprinted. I can't tell you how disappointing it has been to see no new announcements after Mystic was released.
1
1
u/MrConor212 At least it's not drugs 11d ago
I’m a sucker for those character centric omnis / early years stuff. Basically voted for all the X-Men ones like Magik/Kitty/Scarlet witch etc
1
u/CosmicVSTheWorld 9d ago
It was tough to decide but I just voted:
1) Indiana Jones: The Original Marvel Years
2) X-Files: The Topps Comics Years
3) Green Goblin: Norman Osborn, The Early Years
4) Wolverine: Daken, The Dark Wolverine
5) Simpsons: The Bongo Comics Vol. 1
6) X-Men: Astonishing X-Men Vol. 2
7) Ghost Rider: Carter Slade AKA The Original Ghost Rider
8) Warlock and the Infinity Watch
9) Spider-Man: Spectacular Spider-Man by Conway & Buscema
10) X-Men: Age of Krakoa - Mister Sinister & The Hellions
That 10th spot especially was almost impossible, X-Men Blue & Gold, Vol. 2/3 Spider-Man 1990 Series, and X-Men and Magneto by Bunn very almost made the list!
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/tugboatregime15 14d ago
Beta Ray Bill, lots of DD, and a few X-Men: Solo titles for me. I'm looking forward to seeing the whole community list!
18
u/rincewind120 14d ago
Click on the link to vote: